The Validation Journey
From submission to publication — a transparent, expert-driven process that ensures only genuine innovations earn The Circle's seal of validation.
Submission
Innovator submits their innovation through the 5-step wizard with evidence, media, and impact metrics
⏱ ~30 minutesScreening
Admin team reviews for completeness and assigns 2-3 expert validators from the relevant sector and region
⏱ 2-3 daysExpert Validation
Independent validators score across 4 dimensions (Impact, Scalability, Authenticity, Ownership) using the standardized rubric
⏱ 5-7 daysConsensus & Feedback
Scores are aggregated. If below threshold, revision may be requested. If aligned, validation status is awarded
⏱ 1-2 daysPublication
Validated innovations are published to the registry with their tier badge, making them visible to funders and partners
⏱ ImmediateInnovation Status Flow
Every innovation progresses through clear status stages, providing full transparency to innovators and stakeholders.
The 4-Dimension Rubric
Each innovation is scored on four equally-weighted dimensions, totaling 100 points. Click each dimension to explore the detailed scoring criteria.
Validation Tiers
Validated innovations receive a tier badge based on their total score, signaling credibility and readiness to funders and partners.
The minimum validation threshold is 50 points. Innovations scoring below this are given detailed feedback and may resubmit after revisions.
Recently Validated
Innovations that have earned The Circle's seal of validation.